Incident sheet · /security
- System
- Security & Risk
- Filed
- Read
- 3 min · 637 words
- Severity
- Routine
Australia's eSafety Commissioner Dismisses Platform Censorship Warnings
Australia's $109 million Digital Duty of Care bill is in the Senate. eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant rejects claims it will chill free speech, as Google warns of Gmail blocks for under-18s.

Event log
- The Digital Duty of Care bill would fine internet companies up to $109 million for failing to proactively stop user harms
- The bill passed the House of Representatives and needs Senate crossbench support; the government wants it passed by end of year
- eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant told a Senate inquiry she has seen no indication of companies over-censoring in the past two years
- A senior Google Australia executive said the law's age-check provisions might force Gmail to block under-18s
- Meta, TikTok and Snap representatives told the hearing the law gives regulators too much discretion over defining harmful content
Australia's proposed online safety law threatens platforms with fines up to $109 million, and the country's eSafety Commissioner says fears of mass censorship are unfounded. The Digital Duty of Care bill passed the House of Representatives but still needs Senate crossbench support before the end of the year to become law.
eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant told a Senate inquiry she has seen no evidence that platforms are already over-censoring. "I haven't seen any indication, particularly over the past two years, that companies are over-censoring," she said. Her argument rests on incentives, not trust. "Companies today are trying to show the maximum amount of material, no matter how harmful or hurtful it is to the Australian community," she said.
The claim is simple. Engagement-driven business models reward volume, not restraint. Platforms have no commercial reason to remove content pre-emptively, even under threat of nine-figure penalties. Whether that logic survives first contact with $109 million liability exposure is a question the Commissioner did not address.
What does the bill actually require?
The legislation forces internet companies to proactively identify and stop potential user harms. That is a duty of care model, not a takedown model. Platforms must act before regulators ask.
Key elements under debate:
- Proactive harm prevention, backed by fines up to $109 million
- Age checks where there is a risk of a child seeing pornography
- An opt-out from algorithmically recommended content, letting users see posts only from accounts they follow
Industry critics and free speech advocates say the bill gives regulators too much discretion over what counts as harmful. Supporters counter that only a wide-ranging law can deliver an effective safety framework. Both positions were aired at Monday's hearing.
What did the platforms tell the inquiry?
A senior Google executive in Australia warned that the age-check provisions might force the company to block under-18s from Gmail. That is a concrete operational consequence, not an abstraction. If the law reads pornography-exposure risk broadly, a general-purpose email service could fall inside its perimeter.
Representatives from Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, plus TikTok and Snap, raised similar concerns. Their shared position: the law could hand regulators too much discretion to define harm. That discretion, in their telling, pushes platforms toward defensive over-removal to dodge liability.
The Commissioner's rebuttal leaned on data from enforcement. She said most cases of excessive content removal came from automated moderation systems running without human oversight, not from regulatory pressure. Machines, not regulators, are doing the over-censoring that critics cite.
That answer cuts both ways. If automated systems already over-remove at scale without a duty of care, adding $109 million penalties may not improve their accuracy.
What happens next in the Senate?
The bill needs crossbench votes to clear the Senate. The government wants passage by the end of the year. Crossbench senators must now weigh industry warnings against the Commissioner's assurance that market incentives point the other way.
Inman Grant offered one concession to the drafting critique. If lawmakers consider the wording too vague, she said, they should write a narrower definition of harmful content. "If there is opportunity, and we can get some more specificity, this will help us from an enforcement perspective," she told the inquiry.
A regulator asking for narrower scope is notable. It concedes the current text leaves enforcement open to interpretation, the same vagueness the platforms flagged. What she did not say is how a specific definition would coexist with a duty to prevent harms not yet enumerated.
For enterprises operating in Australia, the stakes are concrete. A $109 million maximum penalty, mandatory age assurance, and algorithmic opt-outs would reshape product compliance obligations across search, social and messaging. The Senate timeline is the deadline to watch.
via itnews.com.au (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Staff writer covering technology and product news in enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.
203 articles
The newsroom digest
One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.
Cross-references
- Google warns Australian safety bill could lock under-18s out of Gmail
- EU Digital Fairness Act: Fines Up to 6% of Global Turnover
- Italy Hits Meta With $887 Million Fine Over Facebook Photo Access
- Meta fined $25 billion for sharing user data without consent
- NCPCR to draft social media child-safety rules, finalise in 2027