Incident sheet · /security

Filed
Read
4 min · 729 words
Severity
Routine

Democrats Say Palantir Exec 'Disqualified' Himself as CISA Director Nominee

Palantir's Michael LoSapio faced under an hour of Senate scrutiny, refused to call Jan. 6 an "attack," and drew a Tillis hold as CISA marks two years without a confirmed director.

Dems call CISA nominee ‘disqualified’ after nomination hearing
FeedDems call CISA nominee ‘disqualified’ after nomination hearing — shatishira / pixabay

Event log

  1. CISA has gone without a confirmed director for the first two years of the Trump administration.
  2. LoSapio's hearing lasted less than an hour, bundled with a large tranche of lame-duck nominees.
  3. Sen. Blumenthal said LoSapio 'disqualified' himself by showing a lack of independence from the White House.
  4. Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., announced a hold on the nomination after the hearing.
  5. A Democratic-majority Congress takes office in January, shrinking the confirmation window.

Senate Democrats declared Palantir executive Michael LoSapio "disqualified" from leading the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency after a nomination hearing in which he refused to call the January 6, 2021 Capitol riots an "attack" and would not commit to hiring more staff.

LoSapio, the Trump administration's nominee for CISA director, appeared before the Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee for less than an hour — far less scrutiny than Congress has given previous CISA nominees. Republicans bundled him into a large tranche of nominees they are trying to confirm during the lame duck session.

The agency has operated without a confirmed director for the first two years of the Trump administration, even as policymakers voice fresh concerns about cyber insecurity in U.S. critical infrastructure, artificial intelligence and other threats. Despite that backdrop, LoSapio and the senators spent little time on his vision for the federal government's primary defensive cybersecurity agency.

What did he actually say about cybersecurity?

Asked how he would strengthen national cyber resilience in the wake of last week's widespread outages, LoSapio said organizations should be more proactive in implementing baseline protections around inventory, evaluation and patching of internet-connected devices.

"It's really important to understand the landscape of the systems you have out in the wild," LoSapio said. "The things that you operate day-to-day, the systems that you rely on, the systems that are ancillary, and do an extensive evaluation on their vulnerabilities, whether they've been patched or not, how they've been architected and their defensive capabilities."

He added that there was "more we can do across the nation" to improve security but did not elaborate. He committed only to evaluating the agency's resources once confirmed, not to hiring more staff.

For security leaders, the takeaway is simple: the nominee's stated doctrine amounts to basic hygiene — know your inventory, patch it — with no staffing commitments attached.

Why do Democrats say he is disqualified?

LoSapio waded into several partisan disputes that are likely to complicate his path to confirmation. The sharpest came when Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., pressed him repeatedly on the January 6 riots. LoSapio said he did not view the Capitol assault as an "attack" and doubled down under questioning.

After the hearing, the social media account for Senate Homeland Security Democrats posted the exchange on X and called on the Senate to reject the nomination.

"Anyone who can so easily rewrite history in service to Trump should not be leading CISA, which has critical election security obligations," the post read.

Blumenthal concluded that LoSapio had demonstrated a lack of independence from the White House and had thereby disqualified himself from the role.

What about CISA's funding fight?

The nominee also made claims about agency funding that did not match how shutdowns work. Asked by Sen. Bernie Moreno, R-Ohio, what would happen if "Democrats" did not fund the agency during the lame duck session, LoSapio called the impact "catastrophic" and likened the effect on "ordinary Americans" to calling 9-1-1 and having no one pick up.

Past shutdowns have hindered agency operations, but CISA and other DHS component agencies would continue to operate under emergency appropriations during a shutdown — a contingency LoSapio's comparison overlooked.

Pressed later by Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., on the effects of thousands of firings and hundreds of millions of dollars in cuts over the past two years — plus a White House budget proposal that would cut hundreds of millions more next year — LoSapio said he could not assess them because he was an outsider coming to the agency.

Can he be confirmed before January?

The odds are narrowing. LoSapio's late nomination leaves little runway before January, when a less-friendly, Democratic-majority Congress takes office, forcing him to lobby support from the lame duck Senate. His nomination will also compete for limited floor time: the Trump administration has put forward dozens of federal nominees since the 2026 election.

One Republican obstacle has already emerged. Following the hearing, Punchbowl News reported that retiring Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., announced he would place a hold on LoSapio's nomination — a procedural brake that further squeezes the confirmation timeline.

A hold from a member of the president's own party, combined with unified Democratic opposition, leaves the nominee needing floor time the calendar does not have.

via fedscoop.com (Source)

Filed under

  • cybersecurity
  • cisa
  • critical-infrastructure
  • cyber-resilience
  • federal-agency-leadership
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Correspondent covering regulation, policy and their impact on enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

188 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous article