Incident sheet · /infrastructure

Filed
Read
3 min · 595 words
Severity
Routine

SD-WAN cuts network costs up to 50% versus MPLS, analysis finds

SD-WAN migrations can cut connectivity costs 20-50% and operational costs 30-40% versus MPLS, according to consultant Paul Kirvan, who outlines a five-step ROI calculation framework.

Understand SD-WAN ROI vs. MPLS beyond cost savings
FeedUnderstand SD-WAN ROI vs. MPLS beyond cost savings — SpaceX-Imagery / pixabay

Event log

  1. SD-WAN delivers 20% to 50% connectivity cost savings versus MPLS circuits.
  2. Centralized management reduces operational costs by 30% to 40%.
  3. A five-step framework covers baseline MPLS costs, SD-WAN costs, savings, KPIs and payback period.
  4. ROI formula combines cost savings and operational gains against total SD-WAN investment.
  5. MPLS is a legacy carrier technology from the 1990s using dedicated circuits and predefined paths.

Enterprises migrating from MPLS to SD-WAN can cut connectivity costs by 20% to 50% and operational costs by 30% to 40%, according to an analysis by consultant Paul Kirvan, FBCI, CISA, an independent consultant with more than 35 years of experience in business continuity, cybersecurity and telecom.

SD-WAN (software-defined wide area networking) uses specialized software to route traffic dynamically based on business requirements and available network resources. MPLS (multiprotocol label switching) is a legacy carrier technology developed in the 1990s that routes packets over dedicated transport circuits on predefined paths. Both remain in wide enterprise use, but Kirvan argues the ROI case favors SD-WAN.

What drives the SD-WAN ROI advantage?

The analysis identifies five benefit areas over MPLS:

  • Reduced costs through elimination of MPLS-associated hardware.
  • Security improvements at enterprise and branch levels.
  • Improvements in network management.
  • Application performance improvements and enhanced uptime.
  • Better expense management through intelligent use of multiple network technologies.

Expense reduction is the first key factor. SD-WAN lets network managers substitute cost-effective broadband and wireless connectivity for costly MPLS circuits. The resulting savings range from 20% to 50%, depending on traffic volume and the organization's network architecture. SD-WAN also consolidates networking and security functions and reduces dependence on on-site hardware, which translates into capital expenditure savings. Centralized monitoring and cloud-based management of network functions reduce the need for IT staff travel and facility configuration costs.

How should IT leaders calculate SD-WAN ROI?

Kirvan sets out a five-step framework for organizations migrating from MPLS:

  • Establish the MPLS baseline. Identify existing circuit, hardware, support and maintenance costs. Factor in the time and assets spent on network troubleshooting and provisioning.
  • Estimate SD-WAN costs. Include subscription or licensing fees, training and implementation expenses, and continued managed service costs from the SD-WAN vendor.
  • Examine potential savings. Estimate reductions in connectivity costs, physical devices such as routers and switches, and the impact on support hours for troubleshooting and manual configuration.
  • Track efficiency metrics and KPIs. Monitor mean time to resolution, network uptime percentage, application performance improvements and user satisfaction scores after the migration.
  • Calculate the payback period. This is the time required for cumulative savings to exceed the initial investment.

Quantifying ROI is largely an exercise in assessing cost savings and operational efficiency against MPLS, the analysis states.

What formula compares the two technologies?

IT leaders can use a percentage-based formula:

ROI (%) = (cost savings versus MPLS + operational gains versus MPLS − SD-WAN investment) / SD-WAN investment × 100.

SD-WAN investments include hardware and software costs as well as deployment and training expenses. Cost savings and operational gains comprise lowered connectivity and hardware costs, enhanced security using SASE (secure access service edge, a cloud-delivered networking and security framework), reduced IT personnel costs, productivity enhancements and increased efficiency.

Where does operational efficiency improve?

Improved operational efficiency is the second key differentiator. Centralized management dashboards enable faster service configuration and facility deployment, reducing operational costs by 30% to 40%. Advanced traffic routing and AI-driven analytics increase performance and reliability over MPLS systems.

SD-WAN also scales resources dynamically, and its use of cloud-based resources speeds integration of new locations and supports digital transformation initiatives.

The analysis notes that SD-WAN draws on a variety of network technologies, while MPLS relies on established carrier-based connectivity. Organizations weighing a migration should anchor the business case in the full cost baseline, not headline circuit savings alone, since licensing, training, implementation and managed service fees all count against the investment side of the formula.

via techtarget.com (Source)

Filed under

  • sd-wan
  • mpls
  • network-roi
  • enterprise-networking
  • cost-optimization
Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

199 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous article