Incident sheet · /security

Filed
Read
4 min · 786 words
Severity
Routine

SIM Binding Will Cut Cybercrime by 2-3% at Most, Experts Warn

Experts at MediaNama's roundtable say India's SIM binding order will cut cybercrime by just 2-3%, citing telco KYC gaps, mule SIMs and a December 31, 2026 deadline.

Why SIM binding is the wrong fix for India’s cybercrime problem #NAMA
FeedWhy SIM binding is the wrong fix for India’s cybercrime problem #NAMA — Joa70 / pixabay

Event log

  1. DoT's SIM binding directions, issued November 2025, cover eight platforms including WhatsApp, Telegram and Signal; compliance deadline is December 31, 2026.
  2. Ritesh Bhatia estimates SIM binding will reduce cybercrime by only 2-3%.
  3. An ISB study found 89% of alternate subscriber numbers are not Aadhaar-linked.
  4. Suman Kar: the average scam takes about 5 minutes to pull off.
  5. DoT has since asked for SIM-presence checks every 24 hours; MP Pemmasani Chandra Shekar said in the Rajya Sabha on April 2, 2026 that risk-based analysis will replace six-hour logouts.

India's SIM binding mandate will reduce cybercrime by no more than 2% to 3%, according to Ritesh Bhatia, founding director for cyber incident response and investigations at V4Web Cybersecurity, speaking at MediaNama's virtual roundtable on the technical issues with SIM binding on November 13, 2026.

The rule he was arguing against is the Department of Telecommunications' instruction, issued in November 2025, requiring messaging platforms to bind each account to the KYC-verified SIM in the user's phone. The directions went to eight platforms: WhatsApp, Telegram, Signal, Arattai, Snapchat, ShareChat, JioChat and Josh — and the definition behind them could reach further. A source familiar with the implementation told MediaNama that DoT has since asked for SIM-presence checks every 24 hours. The current compliance deadline is December 31, 2026.

"SIM binding will definitely resolve one issue, which is the WhatsApp takeover," Bhatia said. But those takeover scams are numerous in quantity yet small in losses compared with digital-arrest and investment scams, which is why he puts the rule's impact at roughly 2% or 3%. Even for account takeovers, he argued, mandating strong two-factor authentication would solve the problem.

Is the fix really a fix — or surveillance?

Parag Kar, an independent consultant and telecom expert, put the question more bluntly:

"We can't really say that the problem is not real. What we can ask is whether the solution is actually a solution, or a mechanism for something else, like surveillance."

Meghna Bal, founder and director of Esya Centre and author of a research report on SIM binding, pointed to structural gaps in telecom KYC. "SIM Binding does nothing to solve for SIMs that are acquired through fraudulent means," she said, citing an ISB study that found 89% of alternate subscriber numbers are not Aadhaar-linked.

"Of course, there's an incentive there, right, to not verify with government databases that the credentials you are given are correct, because that will hamper your sales," Bal said. Telcos' incentive, in other words, is an imperfect KYC system that tolerates fraudulent SIM sales.

Beyond subscriber identification, she listed "software-level compromise, credential theft, malware infections, session hijacking" as fraud mechanisms the rule leaves untouched.

What fraud survives the rule?

MediaNama's December 2025 discussion identified the fraud patterns SIM binding would not touch — none of which involve a messaging account running without a SIM in the phone:

  • Phishing
  • Caller ID spoofing
  • OTP theft
  • SIM swaps
  • VoIP-based impersonation
  • Virtual numbers, international numbers and eSIMs
  • Email links and email-based approaches

Experts also warned the rule could hand telcos a commercial windfall if OTP-based or silent mobile verification validates SIM presence. "The reason the mobile operator is pushing for SIM binding is for commercial reasons," said Anand Venkatanarayanan in December 2025. "They want to make money... more SMS means more money, both ways."

Can a logout window stop a five-minute scam?

Bhatia, who works directly with fraud victims, predicted scammers would simply ship a fraudulently KYC'ed SIM — and the phone with it — overseas. "For them the cost of a smartphone is peanuts," he said, describing "mule SIM card holders" like mule bank accounts: a watchman buys the SIM, the device ships to Bangladesh, Burma, Laos or Cambodia. Compared with the crores of rupees a successful scam earns, that cost is "equivalent to me buying a dark chocolate."

Suman Kar, chief executive of Banbreach, timed the crime: the lure call takes two to three minutes, the money exits the financial system in two to three more. "The whole scam takes about 5 minutes to pull off," he said. "Do you really think that a 6-hour, even a 4-hour or a 1-hour window is going to stop people?"

On traceability — a stated goal of DoT's order — he was equally blunt: tracing leads only to the mule holder, not the threat actor abroad.

What does this change for platforms and banks?

Bhatia argued regulation should target where the money flows, not the channels where fraud is merely discussed, and that the Reserve Bank of India should tackle mule accounts first. "It has to be a coordinated effort — not just the DoT, but the DoT with the RBI... along with the banks. And then you get WhatsApp or whoever into the picture," he said.

Bal added that banks and telcos, not messaging platforms, hold the KYC data and can enforce identity-based restrictions. Following the discussion, MP Pemmasani Chandra Shekar told the Rajya Sabha on April 2, 2026 that risk-based analysis will replace standard six-hour web-session logouts. Venkatanarayanan has proposed exactly that: a composite risk index, as banking and UPI apps already use, "without getting involved in SIM binding."

via medianama.com (Source)

Filed under

  • sim-binding
  • cybercrime
  • digital-fraud
  • kyc
  • telecom-regulation
Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

207 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous articleNext article ›