Incident sheet · /security

Filed
Read
4 min · 771 words
Severity
Routine

Delhi High Court Demands Answers on Automated Content Blocking Under IT Rules

Delhi HC has noticed LiveLaw's challenge to IT Rule 4(4): automated blocking of court-reporting reels within 15 minutes, with no order, notice or disclosed authority behind the restrictions.

Delhi HC issues notice on LiveLaw’s challenge to automated content blocking under IT Rules
FeedDelhi HC issues notice on LiveLaw’s challenge to automated content blocking under IT Rules — claudid / pixabay

Event log

  1. Delhi HC issued notice on LiveLaw's challenge to Rule 4(4), IT Rules 2021; Centre and Meta have four weeks to respond; next hearing January 18, 2027
  2. Instagram restricted LiveLaw's Supreme Court reels within about 15 minutes of posting; two of three remain blocked in India
  3. SFLC.in recorded ~268 content and 83 account restrictions across Meta, X, YouTube and Reddit in the first 29 days of October; Instagram accounted for 174
  4. A February 2026 amendment shifted Rule 4(4) from 'endeavour' to a proactive duty to restrict content 'exactly identical' to blocked material
  5. LiveLaw seeks to quash MeitY advisories of October 8 and 10 and to bar automated blocking of news reports without a court order

The Delhi High Court has issued formal notice on LiveLaw's challenge to Rule 4(4) of the IT Rules, 2021, the provision that pushes large social media platforms to use automated tools against content matching already-blocked material. A bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma gave the Centre and Meta four weeks to respond. The case returns to court on January 18, 2027.

The trigger is speed. LiveLaw, a legal-news publisher with a verified Instagram account exceeding 10 lakh followers, says Meta restricted its reels covering Supreme Court proceedings within roughly 15 minutes of posting. It received no blocking order, no notice, and no reasons.

What does the petition actually allege?

LiveLaw's filing argues the rule, as implemented, operates as prior restraint on publication. The petition states: "the impugned Rule, in the form in which it has been implemented, authorises a prior restraint upon publication. The First Reel and the Second Reel were rendered inaccessible within fifteen minutes of their publication, before any human being could have examined a 'legal request', let alone conducted the 'legal and human rights assessment' which Respondent No. 3 claims to have made." Respondent No. 3 is Meta.

The relief sought is broad:

  • Strike down Rule 4(4) as exceeding the IT Act's powers and violating constitutional rights to equality, free speech, trade and life.
  • Quash two MeitY advisories issued October 8 and October 10, which LiveLaw says lack legal basis and underpinned the restrictions.
  • Restore two reels still inaccessible in India.
  • Disclose the legal requests and communications behind the restrictions.
  • Protect news reporting — a declaration that platforms cannot deploy automated blocking against news reports without a court order, or at minimum must issue a reasoned intimation under Rule 3(1)(d).

LiveLaw does not oppose automated tools targeting rape or child sexual abuse material. Its challenge targets blocking of content "allegedly identical" to disabled information, especially court-proceedings reporting.

Which reels were restricted?

The petition details three takedowns on the verified account:

  • October 27: A reel on the Election Commission's Supreme Court affidavit on the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Restricted within 15 minutes; restored that night.
  • October 29: A reel on challenges to the SIR pending before the Supreme Court. Restricted within about 15 minutes; still inaccessible in India.
  • October 30: A reel on Supreme Court proceedings over the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026. Also still blocked in India.

Meta told LiveLaw the content "went against local law" after review. Meta's grievance officer gave no substantive reply to complaints, and neither Meta nor the Centre answered legal notices sent October 30.

What happened in court?

Advocate Apar Gupta, appearing for LiveLaw, told the bench that Instagram took down yet another reel on November 18 — this one reporting the Delhi Police's Supreme Court affidavit arguing that reel makers cannot claim the protections the Court extended to journalists.

"I am under risk of entire account being suspended. The takedown happened last night is of reporting of Supreme Court, Delhi Police affidavit. I am not pressing for interim relief today but a shorter date," Gupta said.

Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, for the Centre, offered to treat the petition as a representation and pass a reasoned order after hearing LiveLaw. LiveLaw's counsel called that "a mere formality." The court also noted similar matters are listed for February 9, 2027.

Why does Rule 4(4) matter here?

The rule originally asked significant social media intermediaries only to "endeavour" to deploy automated tools. A February 2026 amendment hardened that wording; LiveLaw says platforms must now proactively identify and restrict information "exactly identical" to content they have already disabled. The petition argues this lets platforms adjudicate legality themselves, bypassing the safeguards that Section 69A of the IT Act attaches to blocking — safeguards the Supreme Court relied on when it upheld that section in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India.

The backdrop is scale. During October protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, SFLC.in recorded about 268 content restrictions and 83 account restrictions across Meta, X, YouTube and Reddit in the first 29 days of October; Instagram alone accounted for 174 content restrictions. Meta's user notices cited a "legal request," Section 79(3)(b), the IT Rules, or "an automated system" — none named the ordering authority.

The stakes reduce to three points: blocks can land faster than any human review; publishers cannot challenge restrictions whose legal basis remains undisclosed; and the court must now decide whether the 2026 amendment's automated-blocking duty can apply to news reporting at all.

via medianama.com (Source)

Filed under

  • automated-content-moderation
  • it-rules
  • rule-4-4
  • free-speech
  • delhi-high-court
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Correspondent covering regulation, policy and their impact on enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

203 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous articleNext article ›