Incident sheet · /security

Filed
Read
3 min · 547 words
Severity
Routine

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Photo Access

Italy's privacy regulator fined Meta €805 million after Facebook accessed phone galleries of about 20 million Android users without clear consent. Meta must redesign the feature in 60 days.

Italy fines Meta €805 million for accessing Facebook users’ phone photos without clear permission
FeedItaly fines Meta €805 million for accessing Facebook users’ phone photos without clear permission — 652234 / pixabay

Event log

  1. Italy's Data Protection Authority fined Meta €805 million on November 14, roughly 0.47% of global revenue.
  2. Facebook accessed phone galleries of approximately 20 million Android users without specific consent.
  3. Meta must redesign the gallery suggestion feature within 60 days and report initial steps within 30 days.
  4. The regulator found violations of Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code implementing the EU ePrivacy Directive.
  5. Meta will appeal and called the penalty 'disproportionate'.

By Rebecca Stone

Italy's Data Protection Authority fined Meta €805 million on November 14. The regulator found Facebook accessed photos, videos and related data stored on roughly 20 million Android phones without specific consent or adequate information. Meta must redesign the implicated feature within 60 days.

The case targets Facebook's gallery suggestion feature, introduced in 2023. It recommends photos and videos from users' phones for posting while they browse the app.

What did the regulator find?

The authority identified three defects in how Meta obtained permission to access users' galleries:

  • One permission for multiple features. Facebook used a single permission covering several functions instead of seeking separate consent for the gallery suggestion feature.
  • Unclear information. The app displayed a vague message, "enable other functions", without explaining that granting it would allow Facebook to suggest gallery content.
  • Enabled by default. The feature switched on automatically rather than requiring users to activate it.

The regulator found that granting full permission could allow Facebook to access a phone's entire photo library continuously. Neither users nor regulators could determine which files the app accessed.

Which law did Meta violate?

The authority ruled that Meta violated Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the EU's ePrivacy Directive. The law requires freely given and informed consent before accessing information stored on personal devices. That requirement applies even if the information is never transmitted elsewhere or no actual harm is established.

Meta argued Ireland's data protection regulator should handle the case because its European headquarters sit in Ireland. The Italian authority rejected this, explaining that ePrivacy rules do not follow the EU's "one-stop-shop" system (the mechanism that routes cross-border privacy cases to a company's lead regulator).

What must Meta do now?

Meta must obtain separate, informed consent for the gallery suggestion feature. It must explain what information the feature accesses and how users can turn it off.

The company must also switch the feature off by default, including for users who previously granted permission. After 60 days, it cannot activate the feature for anyone without valid consent.

Deadlines are tight. Meta must report initial steps to the regulator within 30 days and detail implemented measures within 90 days.

Did Meta use the photos to train AI?

The investigation did not examine whether Meta used gallery content to train artificial intelligence models, a practice the company denies. The regulator said it may separately investigate a feature introduced in 2026 that allows users' gallery content to be processed in the cloud.

Why was the fine so high?

The regulator cited an earlier enforcement action against Meta in 2019 and the company's limited cooperation during the investigation. Although Meta changed some practices after the complaint, the authority called those measures late and limited because they benefited only users who updated the app. The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47% of Meta's global revenue.

What did Meta say?

Meta said it will appeal the decision and called the penalty "disproportionate".

A Meta spokesperson told Reuters: "This is a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook. Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings."

via medianama.com (Source)

Filed under

  • meta
  • facebook
  • data-privacy
  • eprivacy-directive
  • regulatory-enforcement
Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

199 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous articleNext article ›