Incident sheet · /infrastructure

Filed
Read
4 min · 753 words
Severity
Routine

Ukraine's Starlink outages show why India must build its own space war assets, says CDS

CDS General Raja Subramani cited degraded Starlink service in Ukraine as a warning, urging homegrown space, AI and manufacturing capability at the ANI Security Summit in Delhi.

CDS Raja Subramani highlights Starlink disruption in Ukraine, calls for India’s self-reliant space capabilities
FeedCDS Raja Subramani highlights Starlink disruption in Ukraine, calls for India’s self-reliant space capabilities — WikiImages / pixabay

Event log

  1. CDS General Raja Subramani spoke at the ANI National Security Summit 3.0 in Delhi on November 16
  2. He cited degraded Starlink service in Ukraine, which impaired Ukrainian long-range drones, as a warning for India
  3. Three companies — Jio, OneWeb and Starlink — hold licences in India's satellite communications market
  4. The CDS said industry meeting 60 to 70% of requirements with indigenous IP-controlled resources is acceptable
  5. He named five focus areas: space, algorithmic and data warfare, defence manufacturing, legacy modernisation and talent

When Starlink service degraded over Ukraine, Ukrainian long-range drones lost their efficacy. That single point of failure is exactly the lesson India's Chief of Defence Staff wants the country's defence establishment to internalise.

General NS Raja Subramani delivered that warning on November 16 at the ANI National Security Summit 3.0 in Delhi, arguing that India cannot outsource the space layer on which modern warfare now depends.

"Space will also be increasingly contested. Our adversaries will try to ensure that we are denied the ability to use space," he said. "An example of which we can see in Ukraine when Starlink was denied or degraded, Ukrainian long-range drones lost their efficacy."

What does the CDS want built?

Space has become a crucial enabler of modern warfare, General Raja Subramani said, and India needs stronger satellite-based intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, communication and precision navigation. The Space-Based Surveillance-3 (SBS-3) system, once fully operational, would significantly improve India's capacity — but he stressed the need to expand further for reliable intelligence, communication and satellite navigation.

Self-reliance here means ISRO and the private sector working together, he underlined. His comments come amid ongoing debate over Starlink's proposed entry into India's satellite communications market — an effort that has drawn complaints from SpaceX CEO Elon Musk over alleged obstructions to the company's operations.

The government, for its part, has welcomed all comers and says consumers will decide on price, value and quality. Three companies — Jio, OneWeb and Starlink — currently hold licences to operate in India's satcom market. Operators must meet prescribed security requirements, and the spectrum allocation and pricing framework is still being finalised before commercial services begin.

Five focus areas for future conflict

Beyond space, the CDS named five pillars of self-reliance and preparedness:

  • Space capabilities
  • Algorithmic and data warfare
  • Defence manufacturing
  • Modernisation of legacy systems
  • Human talent development

On AI, he was blunt about the inputs that matter. "Increasingly, artificial intelligence will play a key role in today and in future warfare," he said. "And enablers of artificial intelligence and algorithmic warfare are data, compute, energy, and the ability and access to adequate talent." The defence forces are now working to streamline data, establish clear standards and ensure timely dissemination of information through enhanced networks.

Components, not just assembly

Atmanirbharta — self-reliance — means manufacturing critical components, not merely assembling complete systems, he argued. "It is not enough for our industry to only make systems. We also need to work on the critical components that we require, whether it be servos, whether it be magnetometers, whether it be sensors, we need to manufacture it ourselves or at least have the IP and the technology to manufacture it at scale," he said. He urged domestic industries to build scalable manufacturing capacity.

On legacy equipment, he accepted reality: India will fight with a mix of old and new. "No country can hope to have all modern equipment," he said, calling for legacy platforms to be upgraded with AI and open architectures so they can be networked. "Today we cannot afford to have isolated systems fighting. We have to have a network of systems."

What does industry get in return?

The defence forces will communicate operational requirements rather than prescribe specific equipment, encouraging manufacturers to work directly with military personnel and iterate. The bar for indigenous content is pragmatic. "We are happy if you are able to meet 60 to 70% of our requirement with indigenous resources, but those resources and the IP should be under your control. Only then will we be able to rapidly improve upon it," the CDS said.

He also asked industry to deploy engineers in forward areas to understand operational needs through field feedback, called on academia to focus on research with practical outcomes in close cooperation with end users, praised startups' agility as an expander of the defence technology ecosystem, and pointed technology companies toward software-driven military capability. "Today's warfare will be increasingly defined by the software that underpins the hardware," he said, noting AI and machine learning can speed decisions and improve planning, logistics, surveillance and intelligence.

And none of it works without people. "No amount of technology, no amount of Atmanirbharta, no amount of industrial capacity will succeed if we do not develop our talent," he said, calling for collaboration among the forces, industry and academia.

His closing message was a call to speed and scale — the ability to fight with what India has, sustain it, and win.

via thenewsmill.com (Source)

Filed under

  • space-warfare
  • satellite-communications
  • defence-self-reliance
  • defence-manufacturing
  • artificial-intelligence
Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

207 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous articleNext article ›