Incident sheet · /applications
- System
- Enterprise Applications
- Filed
- Read
- 4 min · 732 words
- Severity
- Routine
Oracle and VA face Senate grilling as EHR contract ceiling hits $27B
Oracle Health's VA EHR contract ceiling grew from $10B to $27B. Senators demanded answers; GAO now pegs total lifecycle cost at $56.5B through 2031 and beyond.

Event log
- VA's EHRM contract ceiling with Oracle Health rose from $10 billion to $27 billion, finalized in August after an $18.5B proposal was negotiated down to just under $17B.
- GAO puts full lifecycle cost at $37.2B to reach all 170 sites by 2031, plus $19.3B for a decade of sustainment — $56.5B total.
- System scale grew from 85,000 to 195,000 concurrent users and from about 60 to about 190 interfaces.
- Evans said VA has gone a year without a complete outage and shipped over 13,000 user-driven improvements.
- VA plans 26 more site deployments next year.
The ceiling on the Department of Veterans Affairs' electronic health record modernization contract with Oracle Health has grown from $10 billion to $27 billion, and on Wednesday the Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee demanded to know why Congress learned of it largely through news reports.
Oracle Co-CEO Mike Sicilia and Neil Evans, program executive director of the VA's EHRM Integration Office, offered a consistent defense: the size, scope, timeline and the product itself have all changed, so the price changed with them.
"I'm not here to declare victory," Sicilia said. "I'm also not here to say that everything is perfect with the system, but the scope of the system, the scale of the system has changed dramatically."
How did a $10 billion contract become $27 billion?
According to Sicilia's prepared remarks for Thursday's House Veterans' Affairs Committee hearing, Oracle proposed an $18.5 billion increase over two months this summer. Negotiations cut that to just under $17 billion, made official in August.
The drivers, per the witnesses, include:
- A changed deployment timeline and a two-year pause nobody priced in originally
- Work the VA once planned to take over but, as Evans put it, "has since realized that it is better for Oracle to continue managing"
- New requirements added from lessons learned
- COVID-19 pandemic delays, customizations and "inadequate infrastructure from Cerner that impacted system stability"
Sicilia also cited raw scale figures. The system was sized for 85,000 concurrent users; it now supports 195,000. Interfaces grew from roughly 60 to about 190. Pricing stays the same, he said, labor costs rose a few percent, and the deal includes free access to clinical AI.
"The sheer amount of scope increases and the two-year pause could not have been anticipated at that time," Sicilia said, adding: "We understand Congress has to decide the value and whether to continue investing taxpayer dollars."
What does this change for taxpayers?
The numbers keep climbing past the contract ceiling. Carol Harris, the GAO's director of IT and cybersecurity, told the committee the full lifecycle cost to go live at all 170 sites by 2031 is $37.2 billion, with another $19.3 billion to operate and sustain the system for a decade — $56.5 billion in total. At a Sept. 2 House hearing, VA Deputy Secretary Paul Lawrence had estimated about $11 billion for sustainment, roughly $48 billion all in.
Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., dismissed the project as having "all the hallmarks of a failed execution" rather than a platform problem. "Nobody can rationalize a fourfold increase in the cost of a project without somebody's head rolling," he said, adding he would bet money Oracle returns for more beyond the $37 billion because "all I've heard are the same words applied to a new set of numbers."
What about the 2022 promise to absorb costs?
Sicilia pledged in 2022 that Oracle would absorb costs above the original $10 billion ceiling tied to performance or workflow issues. On Wednesday he called it a "sincere commitment" that still stands, born of a "desire to be the best partner that we could be." Oracle has absorbed "many" items, he said, including stabilizing the system, migrating it to Oracle's cloud, and improving performance and workflows.
Evans said he first grasped the magnitude of the cost rise in September 2025, when full lifecycle figures went to the committee. Harris noted the GAO has waited over a year for the underlying analysis behind the VA's estimate. When Evans mentioned an agreement to hand over documentation, Chairman Jerry Moran, R-Kan., cut in: "Why do you need an agreement? Just do it."
The VA's estimate is "informed by predictable and now validated real-world costs," Evans said, and the agency has "high confidence" it can finish deployments within $37.2 billion. Ranking member Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., said he was "troubled" Congress learned of the ceiling hike from reporters; Evans replied there was "not an intentional decision to not notify Congress."
Technically, the system is stable, Evans said: a year without a complete outage and more than 13,000 improvements shipped from user feedback. The VA wants 26 more site deployments next year, though Blumenthal insisted future rollouts must hinge on demonstrated readiness, not an "arbitrary schedule." Moran, for his part, thanked the witnesses for "progress" — concerns remaining notwithstanding.
via fedscoop.com (Source)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.
185 articles
The newsroom digest
One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.
Cross-references
- Oracle Execs Face Congress Over $17B VA Health Record Hike
- West Sussex Oracle ERP rollout delayed again as costs climb 15-fold
- Oracle Pours $1.5 Billion Into Its AI Data Platform Push
- VA.gov Redesign Draws on 90,000 Veteran Surveys; LLM-Friendly Updates Next
- Pentagon Bets Its 2028 Clean Audit on an $821M Data Platform