Incident sheet · /applications

Filed
Read
4 min · 863 words
Severity
Routine

Oracle Execs Face Congress Over $17B VA Health Record Hike

Subpoenaed Oracle executives testify before House and Senate Veterans' Affairs Committees this week as lawmakers probe the VA's $17 billion contract hike to $27 billion.

Here’s how Congress, stakeholders are preparing for Oracle execs to testify on VA EHRM
FeedHere’s how Congress, stakeholders are preparing for Oracle execs to testify on VA EHRM — 12019 / pixabay

Event log

  1. VA raised the Oracle Health EHR contract ceiling by $17 billion, from $10 billion to $27 billion
  2. Oracle co-CEO Mike Sicilia and EVP Seema Verma testify Nov. 19-20; Larry Ellison on Dec. 10
  3. House committee unanimously subpoenaed Sicilia and Ellison on Sept. 2
  4. VA's full EHRM rollout is estimated at $37.2 billion through 2031
  5. Rollout targets 26 hospital deployments in 2027 and every VA facility by 2031

The Department of Veterans Affairs dropped a $17 billion surprise on Congress two months ago, and this week Oracle's executives have to explain it — under subpoena, on the record, and in public.

Co-CEO Mike Sicilia, joined by Executive Vice President Seema Verma, testifies Wednesday afternoon before the Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee and Thursday morning before its House counterpart. Chairman and Chief Technology Officer Larry Ellison is slated for the House committee on Dec. 10.

Sicilia and Ellison were unanimously subpoenaed by the House panel on Sept. 2 after Verma skipped a hearing citing "time constraints and the two panel structure of the hearing."

"Oracle must appear publicly before this committee to answer for its performance and how the additional billions of dollars it will receive will benefit veterans," House ranking member Rep. Mark Takano, D-Calif., said at the time. Wednesday's Senate session, by contrast, was previewed voluntarily by committee Chair Jerry Moran, R-Kan.

How did a $10 billion contract become $27 billion?

That's the question Democrats keep asking. The original ceiling was $10 billion. It rose to $27 billion — a 170% increase — without widespread knowledge in Congress, and Democratic lawmakers have sent letters to both VA and Oracle demanding answers.

"Under the Trump administration, VA chose to rapidly accelerate the deployment of the Oracle Health product, despite no proven record of success and no assessment as to whether VA's workforce and infrastructure could withstand such efforts," their letter said. "VA's decline in transparency, particularly regarding recent contract modifications, is extremely troubling."

VA spokesperson Quinn Slaven counters that Congress was told a year ago: the agency notified Sen. Richard Blumenthal, Rep. Takano and other members in September 2025 that the full EHRM rollout would cost an estimated $37.2 billion through 2031.

A committee minority spokesperson isn't buying it. "We did not consider that estimate reliable because they never showed their math, we had no idea what was included in that cost," they told FedScoop, adding that GAO and Democratic leaders have repeatedly told VA its estimates don't meet best practices.

And one number was never disclosed at all: "At no point did VA indicate to us that, of that $37.2 billion estimate, Oracle would receive nearly $27 billion."

Blumenthal and six other Senate minority members backed the subpoenas in a late-September letter: "Your failure to appear in Congress is a failure to uphold your commitment to veterans and we need immediate answers on this project."

Separately, House Chairman Mike Bost, R-Ill., wrote to OPM Director Scott Kupor last week flagging another VA-Oracle modernization effort that needs "clear accountability, adequate resources, and safeguards against disruption."

Is the rollout actually working?

VA says yes. Oracle's EHR just went live at the 12th and 13th VA medical centers this year — Anchorage, Alaska, and Cleveland, Ohio — "and had no problems at all," VA Secretary Doug Collins said Friday at a Hudson Institute event.

Deputy Secretary Paul Lawrence went further, telling ABC's News 5 Cleveland that critics are "very present-level luddites" foolish to think the legacy VistA system could match what's coming. "The success we saw this year lays the groundwork for deployments in 26 hospitals in 2027, and meeting our goal of ensuring EHR is in every VA facility by 2031," Lawrence said.

Collins credits standardizing roughly 90% of the Oracle product across all VA medical centers. He also sees no exit ramp: "I don't have an option. This is what we use now. It's expensive. It's going to be, but I challenge Congress or anybody else to sit there and say, 'why are we allowing veterans to not have the ability to have an electronic health records system that is mimicked in every part of the world?'" On the $17 billion ceiling increase, he noted: "all funding still comes from Congress."

What do clinicians and veterans groups want?

The National Association of VA Physicians and Dentists, with co-signing medical organizations, wants Congress to withhold funding for further deployments — limiting money to patient care at converted sites until VA proves the system supports "safe, reliable care." They want an independent comparison of continuing with Oracle versus another vendor or modernizing VistA.

"Design flaws disrupt core workflows, basic tasks take far longer than before, critical information is harder to find, and serious technical failures put patients at risk," the NAVAPD letter said, citing the 2024 VA-confirmed Oracle failures deemed a "potentially causal factor" in the deaths of six veterans.

Other groups want accountability, not a stop. "Support for modernization should never mean exemption from accountability," said Theophlius Watson of the Association of VA Social Workers. "We should not confuse the speed of implementation with the success of implementation."

IAVA CEO Kyleanne Hunter said veterans "deserve answers, not partisan finger-pointing." The American Legion warned that "the experience of the first sites shows the consequences when schedule outpaces readiness."

The VFW's Gregg Orto "strongly supports" continuing without delay. AMVETS' Joe Chenelly said the rising costs "seem appropriate so far" — with one caveat: waiting to see whether sworn testimony matches what's said behind closed doors.

via fedscoop.com (Source)

Filed under

  • oracle-health
  • veterans-affairs
  • electronic-health-records
  • government-contracts
  • ehr-modernization
Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around enterprise information technology and the leaders who run at CIO Monitor.

207 articles

The newsroom digest

One email a day with the stories that matter. No noise.

By subscribing you agree to the privacy policy.

Cross-references

‹ Previous articleNext article ›